Voting Sage now, I reckon Gueritol was our vigilante, well done whoever you were.

well since i was so wrong the first time, might as well make it up this time.

You know what would be the funniest thing. Chunky is probably the vigilante.

This is a reprint of my earlier post with who voted for who on Day 1:

* = DEAD (or soon will be)

Townie:
darkguy00000 – mwmoss
* Nebuchadnezer – mwmoss - mason
Renno - Sage
* mwmoss - Sage - detective
tarim - Sage
The Biscuit - Sage

Mafia:
* Sage - mwmoss - was mafia
* kong - mwmoss - was mafia

Unsure:
Coopels – mwmoss
Chunky50 – mwmoss
Corflu - mwmoss
Gueritol – Sage
Sanshiro Sugata – mwmoss
Bud_Chevy – mwmoss
Wasteland – was Sage, but switched to none when it got tight (suspicious)

I still feel fairly good about this list. Better now that the two I suspected of being mafia are dead. The odds are again with the townies.

The mafia probably had three vote for mwmoss, and one vote for Sage. Of the people who voted for Sage on my list of unknowns, I was thinking that Gueritol might be mafia, but now with the weird unvote from Wasteland, he's high on my suspicious list. Of the people who voted for mwmoss, Coopels is high on my list at the moment. It is conceivable that he was just voting with his clanmate like Neb was. But Neb was just genuinely confused. Coopels acted like he knew what he was doing. But so far, this is speculation. Just wanted to let everyone know what my thoughts were to date, in case I get killed by mafia on night 2.

Also, Sanshiro's a possibility too based on some of his posts.

sage is a dead man

as I read the story all townies were falc leaders no? obi said nothing about neb being a mason. And dang that bouncy neb! I could have sworn he was mafia!

lucky hit on kong and it's good we got 1 who had no ties! now we can explore those that DID have ties and we are free of the wild card.

high on suspicious list...coop, SS, neb, oh wait he's dead...well let's start with sage and bring out the dogs for the other 2

Per Oblivion's post: 2 Masons (Falc Leaders)

No, the falcs are normal townies and the falc leaders are the masons.

Wait! I can explain myself. I know, obviously, I wasn't the detective.

But I was the doctor. I didn't want to CLAIM doctor, because I'd get night killed...and I was kind of hoping that the mafia would counterclaim, and then we could get a mafia and let the real detective stay hidden.

Obviously it didn't work...but don't lynch me.

LOL @ Sage. Give it up! Townies don't lie, you did. You're mafia, thru and thru.

Oblivion lied all the time when he was a townie. I knew my play was a bit odd, but I thought it would work. I actually had darkguy pegged as the detective. So I figured, darkguy being in Australia, there was a huge chance that the mafia would log online before him and counterclaim. Then darkguy, afraid of getting into another "I'M Spartacus!!!" fiasco like happened in Cult Mafia, would sit back and let things play out.

Would you guys have preferred I claimed doctor and gotten nightkilled? Obviously, I'd get nightkilled tonight (now), but it's better than wasting our lynch on the doctor.

Oblivion drooled on himself. You know better. The sooner we kill you off, the less drivel we have to listen to.

Yeah, shut the **** up, Sage.

Oddly enough Sage's correct, but I'm sure he was going to fall back onto that. Still, I'm voting him.

Also we need to readjust the roles, I think:

Town: Falchs.
Masons: HC.
Vigilante: Marksman.
Detective: Scout.
Doctor: Commandeer.
Mafia: Ryder.

THEN we'd be right .

Too bad we didn't have those adjusted roles earlier.

Everyone know moss doesn't grow on a rolling ryder, whereas the sagebrush is always ryding in the wind. It would have been so easy!

Well here we go again with the plot, over plot, over plot.

I think Sage again is playing us. I have to admit, he's excellent. But no fuzzy dice for you mister.

This town need to be back to it's formwer healthy days, without organized crime ... and plenty of work.

I'm voting for Sage.

I just don't get this! Neb was one of the leaders of the movement against mwmoss, yet he is dead by the mafias!!?? I am confused.

Perhaps he is dead from his "experience" factor, but if mwmoss was not mafia I was looking at Neb as a ringleader since was so much for it. What was it in Neb's posts that aroused a threat other than his 'vet' factor? I am going to have to reread all that...

Also, do we know if the detective was able to investigate anyone and annouce their affiliation before his demise? Does not look like it to me.

Six votes already sage.. you can save what drama you have left.. I think that enough was used day one to get us to kill our own detective..

The bad thing is that I voted for you first, but had a real difficult time with the counter claim.. should have believe moss and not changed my vote.

Seven now Bud! And I wish I had left my vote as it was too...I just knew that whole D-E-T-E-C-T-I-V-E thing wasn't right.

You are a master at persuasion Sage, I'll give you that.

Not sure who the vigilante is, but excellent guess! At least we took out 2 mafia for the loss of our detective.

I'm going back to reread some posts and recheck the votes and come back with another post shortly.

One thing to note. I think the detective DID do his job really. The Biscuit was pushing hard for Sage as a culprit and to stay off mwmoss even against the odds. To me there is just no way I can see The Biscuit being mafia. So put him on your 'buddy' list guys.

Well, duh!

Also, Bud's reminder to himself and anyone who'll listen "The bad thing is that I voted for you first".
Does this not make you laugh? It does me.